Alleged Contradictions in the Accounts of Joseph Smith's First Vision

Home > First Vision Sandbox > Alleged Contradictions in the Accounts of Joseph Smith's First Vision

Alleged Contradictions in the Accounts of Joseph Smith's First Vision

This page is still under construction. We welcome any suggestions for improving the content of this FAIR Answers Wiki page.

Summary: Critics have routinely asserted that Joseph Smith's account of the First Vision contain contradictions. This page gathers all the alleged "contradictions" and clarifies each, showing that Joseph Smith's accounts can easily be harmonized.


One or Two Personages?

Fire or Light?

The Lord or an Angel

Joseph’s Age at the Time of First Vision

Joseph’s Motivation for Seeking Guidance from God

Forgiveness of Sins

Finding True Church

1832 Account Not Mentioning a “New Dispensation”

Knowing if God Existed

Were All the Churches False or Not?

Forbidden or Not Forbidden from Joining Other Churches